The Awards Committee�s efforts focus on reviewing
applications for six awards: APS Postdoctoral Fellowship in Physiological
Genomics; Research Career Enhancement Award; Teaching Career Enhancement
Award; Arthur C. Guyton Award for Excellence in Integrative Physiology;
Shih-Chun Wang Young Investigator Award; and Lazaro J. Mandel Young
Investigator Award.
Based on the number of applicants, the APS Postdoctoral
Fellowship in Physiological Genomics is clearly the most attractive as it
receives the most applications of all the awards. The number of applications
for the APS Postdoctoral Fellowship in Physiological Genomics was down this
year from 30 applications in January 2007 to 24 in January 2008. This
represents a 20% decrease in applications from the preceding year.
The number of applications for the RCEA was 11 this
spring, which represents an increase from the seven received in the fall of
2007 and the nine received in the spring of 2007. Only one application for
the TCEA award was received for the spring 2008 award. This remains
consistent with the number of applications received for the TCEA in the fall
and spring of 2007. This award continues to attract few applicants.
The Committee tracks the gender distribution of
applicants, recipients and the Committee composition. The gender
distribution of the applicants for the 2008 APS Postdoctoral Fellowship
Award was 50% women (12 women) and 50% men (12 men). The gender distribution
of the Award winners was 100% men. The gender distribution of the applicants
for the Spring RCEA was 27% women (3 women) and 73% men (8 men). The gender
distribution of the Award winners was 20% women (1 woman) and 80% men (4
men). The gender distribution of the applicants and award winners for the
Spring TCEA competition was 100% female as one woman applied and was
recommended for an award.
The Committee will continue to track this information
and discuss ways to increase the number of women applying for awards. The
Chair plans to work on this issue with the Women in Physiology Committee.
Review Criteria: Standardized review and scoring
criteria are employed for all of the awards. Such standardization makes
identification of outstanding applicants grounded on objective and weighted
factors, and facilitates the job of the Committee.
Awards Committee Meeting: The APS Awards Committee met
at the Experimental Biology Annual Meeting in San Diego, CA. At that
meeting, the Committee discussed ideas on how to increase the number of
applications. A few changes in the review process were instituted at that
meeting and include: shortening the application materials by requesting a
four-page NIH-type biosketch rather than a full CV from the Mentor and
Applicant; the median of the reviewers� scores will also be calculated in
addition to calculating the mean in order to minimize skewing due to
outlying scores; each reviewer will have the opportunity to discuss an
application and attempt to convince their peers of the applications� merits
as long as the application is one of their top ranking three, even if all
the other reviewers scored the application poorly; and for the RCEA and TCEA
applications, reviewers will now read all of the applications (as long as
the numbers of applicants remain roughly 7-12) so that reviewers can select
their top three applicants from a larger pool.
2008 Award Recipients
Postdoctoral Fellowship Award in Physiological
Genomics
The Awards Committee received 24 applications for the
Postdoctoral Fellowship Award in Physiological Genomics. Applications were
generally of exceptional quality. Two Fellowships were awarded this year to:
Ralph J. van Oort, PhD, Department of Molecular Physiology and Biophysics,
Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX; Sean M. Garvey, PhD, Laboratory of
Atherogenesis, Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, Department of Medicine,
The Robert M. Berne Cardiovascular Research Center, Univ. of Virginia.
The APS Postdoctoral Fellowship in Physiological
Genomics has been established in recognition of the fact that many advances
in genomics ultimately require a functional understanding in the context of
the organism, and special training is needed to conduct this type of
research. The ideal candidate is one who has completed outstanding work in a
top-flight graduate program (e.g., molecular biology, genetics, etc.) and
who has the intention of employing organ system approaches during his/her
postdoctoral training. Alternatively, a well-trained graduate in integrative
physiology might wish to expand his/her work through the use of molecular
biological tools and genomics. A central criterion of the postdoctoral
project requires the scientist to use the tools of cellular and molecular
biology in the setting of the whole animal.
A candidate for this program should identify a
laboratory within the United States and a sponsor who is an APS Member in
good standing under whose supervision a project in organ system physiology
and molecular biology/genomics can be combined. The laboratory host/sponsor
must be a member of the American Physiological Society, and it is
anticipated that award recipients will join the Society.
The award funds cover a two-year period and include an
annual stipend for the first year of $37,000, plus a trainee allowance of
$3,500; and a second-year stipend of $39,000, plus a trainee allowance of
$3,500. The award does not include an indirect cost reimbursement. Adequate
progress must be demonstrated by a written report submitted to the APS
following the first year before a second year stipend and trainee allowance
can be awarded.
The Research Career Enhancement (RCEA) and Teaching
Career Enhancement (TCEA) Awards
For the April 2008 deadline, 11 RCEA and 1 TCEA
applications were received. Five RCEA awards were made to: Maureen Basha,
Department of Pharmacology and Physiology, Drexel Univ. College of Medicine,
Philadelphia, PA; Jason R. Carter, Department of Exercise Science, Health
and Physical Education, Michigan Technological University, MI; Michael S.
Hedrick, Department of Biological Sciences, California State University,
East Bay, Hayward, CA; Alexander A. Mongin, Department of Neuropharmacology
and Neuroscience, Albany Medical College, Albany, NY; and Thomas H.
Reynolds, IV, Department of Exercise Science, Skidmore College, Saratoga
Springs, NY.
One TCEA award was made to: Reem R. Abraham, Melaka
Manipal Medical College (Manipal Campus), Manipal, Karnataka, India.
Young Investigator Awards
The APS has three Young Investigator Awards: Arthur C.
Guyton Award for Excellence in Integrative Physiology, Shih-Chun Wang Young
Investigator Award, and Lazaro J. Mandel Young Investigator Award. The 2008
due date for these awards is November 1, 2008.